Best Broiler/ Sheet Pan/ Baking Pan 2025 Reviews (America’s Test Kitchen)

A broiler pan is cookware with a hollow coated metal plate designed to collect grease and juice from cooking or roasting roast fish and meat. Using a broiler pan, you need a minute amount of oil and, in the long run, help you save a couple of bucks.

More importantly, these kitchen aids offer a wide range of health benefits using them. Aside from that, they are faster to grill, broil, or bake with.

But, choosing the right one never come easier, considering the dozens of options on the market. Fortunately, we’ve done the homework and expertly handpicked the best broiler pan to offer excellent values and complete your kitchenware.

Reviews of Top 7 Best Broiler/ Sheet Pan America’s Test Kitchen

Here are top rated broiler pan on the market today

#1. Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan

Are you in the market for a practical and durable pan to help make healthy meals with? Then look no further, our top choice – Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan – is an ideal choice.

When it comes to durability, this unit comes with a steel core to offer this pan incredibly sturdy. On top of that, it features a porcelain finish, which makes it cooking surface non-sticky. This feature means you don’t have to grease the pan too much before you can prepare your meals.

Further, this pan comes with some drawbacks, which include the coating chipping off, and also the perforated top makes it very hard to clean by hand. More so, there is a lot of small indents, which means you have to be scrub them individually. Trust me; this can be really time-consuming.

This pan is dishwasher safe, but it’s advisable to wash by hand to ensure clean pan and free from stubborn food remains. It functions just as other broiler pans on our review. Also, this model is a top choice for cooking vegetables, fish, and meat. Another thing is its small size, which means it’ll fit in any oven and your dishwasher. Keep in mind that this pan may not be able to cook for a lot of people.

Pros:

• Quality build
• Non-stick surface
• Dishwasher safe
• Versatile cooking options

Cons:

• The top isn’t easy to clean thoroughly
• Coating chips offer after awhile

#2. Best Pan for Steaks By Granite Ware Bake, Broil, and Grill Pan

The Granite Ware comes in a set of three pieces. One for broiling, another for baking, and the last one are designed for grilling. The most striking thing about the set is their ability to fuse together to create a fantastic trio.

Like any top product in the market, this pan features a drip tray, which is the baking tray when grilling or broiling with this unit. That’s not all: every piece in this set comes with a carbon steel core, which speaks a lot of the durability of this pan.

Also, this makes Granite Ware are more efficient in terms of energy, which means they have speedy heat-up time even when there’s less heat. One of the main properties of this set is its superior browning property and uniform heat distribution.

This roaster’s exterior and baking pan is lined with porcelain coat, which makes each piece’s surface durable and non-stick. Besides, Granite Ware Bake, Broil, and Grill Pan is quite hardy and made of food-safe stainless steel – PTFE, and PFOA free. Also, it’s dishwasher safe as well.

Pros:

• Broil/broil /grill function pans
• Non-stick features
• Dishwasher safe
• Even heat distribution
• Carbon steel core for better efficiency and durability
• PFOA and PTFE free

Cons:

• Tend to wrap under intense heat
• Non-stick coating chips off with time

#3. Broiler Pans for Ovens by Range Kleen

This is another pan from Range Kleen. This pan is one of the best broiler pans for ovens on the market. This unit comes with a two-piece heavy-duty porcelain-enameled black steel broiler rack and pan.

This authentic OEM Range Kleen pan is crafted using sturdy porcelain-enameled steel to ensure this unit serves you for many years. This unit is designed to be sturdy with a non-stick surface. Besides, all you have to do crank up your oven and allow this pan with rank to do the rest.

Talking about size, this broiler pan comes in a perfect size, not too small, and not too big. The perfect-sized pan ensures it isn’t hard to store and clean while holding a reasonable cooking surface area to hold large cuts.

Even better, this model is totally dishwasher, which cleaning does not have to be tedious and exhausting.

Pros:

• Dishwasher safe
• Non-stick surface
• Durable and sturdy construction
• Includes a rack

Cons:

• Enamel tends to get discolored

#4. Norpro 273 Broil/Roast Pan Set

The Norpro 273 consists of a two-piece in a set. Both pieces offer allows you to roast and broil your food. The top of these units features a perforated design to allow oil drip drain to the other pan. Both pieces in these settings are made of stainless steel, which ensures that they are durable.

But, not just that: Norpro 273 is totally dishwasher safe. This means you can enjoy your favorite meal as soon as you are done with cooking. They are great for boneless chicken, bread, vegetables, shellfish, loin cuts of meat and ribs since it comes with a hollow bottom pan.

This incredible design ensures that this product can hold a considerable amount of oil. Nevertheless, this product is easy to clean and an ideal choice for one or two-person servings.

Pros:

• Dual function – roast and broil
• Crafted from durable stainless steel
• Dishwasher safe
• Drip tray to hold the excess oils

Cons:

• Not non-stick

#5. SmartChoice Basic Broiler Pan

This model is another top choice for people looking to purchase a non-stick broiler pan. With this model, cleaning becomes a breeze. SmartChoice Basic Broiler Pan includes a bottom tray to help collect any excess oil cooking with this unit.

Even more, the bottom tray ensures you can bake and roast separately. Further, the pan offers a uniform heat distribution to cook your meals perfectly. SmartChoice Basic Broiler Pan is designed to work with just about any oven. Lastly, it helps ensure healthier cooking without much stress.

Pros:

• Even heat distribution
• Easy clean-up
• Works well with almost all ovens
• Healthier cooking

Cons:

• The edges are rough, which may cause trouble or so

#6. TeamFar Toaster Oven Pan Tray with Cooling Rack, broiler Pan

This model is another cool product from TeamFar, coming with solid stainless steel without any sort of plating. This set includes a toaster oven rack and pans to offer non-toxic and healthy cooking experience.

The pan’s lid is smoothly rolled to ensure the edges are round without any sharp angles to cause harm. Also, its exquisite craft features a cooling rack weaved strongly with robust stainless steel lines to ensure your food doesn’t fall through the cooking racks.

Cleaning this pan and rack is dishwasher safe, making it totally easy. This pan has a shiny look with a non-stick coating surface without chemicals. This means you can cook without toxic getting into your food.

Furthermore, this wired rack is kept above the juice and can be easily separated from the pan for even cooling. Even better, TeamFar Toaster Oven Pan Tray with Cooling Rack offers you versatile cooking options.

Pros:

• Easy to clean
• Includes cooking racks
• Sturdy craft
• Multiple cooking options

Cons:

• Poor welding

#7. General Electric WB48X10056 Large Broiler Pan and Rack

The General Electric WB48X10056 Large Broiler Pan and Rack comes with a large cooking surface, which makes it an ideal choice for people looking to feed a large number of people. Including two-piece per pan, the drip pan also works great as a baking pan.

The General Electric WB48X10056 is durable, with such industrial-grade steel core construction, you can’t expect anything less. Not just that, the exterior features a porcelain coating, which makes it non-stick. These features combined offer fast and uniform heat distribution.

Pros:

• Large cooking surface
• Dishwasher compatible
• Fast and even heat distribution
• Non-stick surface

Cons:

• Edges are sharp

Things to Consider Before Choosing the Best Broiler Pan

Obviously, several broiler pans are coming from a different manufacturer, which means there is not a one-size-fits-all options on the market. Therefore, you should consider a pan that would come with your oven or microwave.

Without further ado, let’s dive into crucial factors to consider when shopping for a broiler pan:

Product size

The size of the pan is the first place to start. You need to consider the number of people you are looking to feed. You don’t want to end up with a small pan that can feed your family and probably a couple of friends at once.

However, you should remember how the amount of space your microwave or oven offers. You need to make you the pan you purchasing will fit into this equipment. Else, you will be left with a totally useless unit.

Non-stick Surface

Opting for a non-stick surface is a smart buy for a couple of reasons. This feature allows you to cook with a small amount of butter and oil. Cooking on a non-stick pan surface cooks your food with perfection, making it very smooth and comes with great texture.

Quality Construction

It’s often recommended that you opt for steel construction when it comes to utensils and other kitchenwares, and this pan is no exception. While there are different types such as Porcelain, stainless steel will always offer a good value for the money. They are often of high quality and brings a lot of benefits to the table.

Other Features

Aside from non-stick surfaces, you should also consider even and fast heating. It’s important that your broiler pan comes with a drip tray and wide-enough holes to avoid clogging. However, it should not be too wide to allow your food to fall through.

Also, keep in mind that holes with wide space are much easier to clean. Further, for those with a dishwasher, then opting for a dishwasher compatible broiler pan is a smart purchase.

Versatility

Some pans can grill, broil, and bake as well. Therefore, having cookware allowing multiple cooking options can be cost-effective and save space in your cabinet.

Conclusion

We’ve carefully handpicked the best broiler pan on the market. But the choice is yours. If you have trouble making a smart pick, check out our buying guide section to ensure you make an informed decision.