The Best Pizza Stones for Grill/ Oven Of Test Kitchen Reviews 2022

Do you love to cook and eat pizza at all times? 

The first step to satisfying your craving for pizza at all times is getting a quality pizza stone. What makes the best pizza is not just the ingredients and toppings but the tool used in baking it. A pizza stone is a flat slab used in baking. It is similar to baking your pizza in an enclosed oven.

Pizza stones help you make yummy pizza at home with all the ingredients and toppings selected by you. It can endure intense heat to bake them uniformly. The heating of the dough starts from the base before getting to the top of the pizza.

There are usually invisible pores that wick the moisture from the pizza giving you a crispy crust. Without further ado, let’s dive into the 8 best pizza stones for grill available on the market.

Reviews of The Best Pizza Stone for Grill Test Kitchen

Here are top rated Pizza Stone For Grill on the market today

#1- Cuisinart CPS-445, 3-Piece Pizza Grilling Set

A budget-friendly 3-piece pizza grilling set from Cuisinart, a renowned kitchenware brand. It features a ceramic stone made with cordierite, a pizza cutter, and a pizza peel.

The 13-inch cordierite pizza stone heats up quickly and retains the heat across the surface for even grilling. This product can withstand heat up to 800 degrees and is used for other foods such as toast, bagels, waffles.

The pizza peel comes with foldable handles that allow for easy storage and easy handling. The stainless steel pizza peel allows you to easily flip, remove, and transfer your pizza.

The pizza cutter allows you to accurately slice through your pizza with speed. This pizza stone set is cleaned manually and comes with a limited one year warranty.

Pros

• Affordable
• Additional pizza accessories
• A year warranty
• Round shaped
• Excellent heat retention

Cons

• The pizza stone is not too thick.
• Requires additional care

#2- Cast Elegance Pizza Stone for Ovens & Grills

This pizza stone is built to last with engineered tuff cordierite. It is safe to use for grilling your pizza on all kinds of grills such as pellet grills, coal grills and is FDA approved. This product can handle hot temperatures because it was fired at 2000 degrees and does not leach any toxic substances into your food. It doesn’t smell when in use or adds flavour to your foods.

Cast Elegance pizza stone includes a polycarbonate scraper, a manual, and access to an online recipe book. This product is a 14-inch stone that offers you crispy crust pies. The thermarite surface soaks up more fluid while protecting the pizza from extreme heat. The scraper aids the removal and manoeuvering of pies. The recipe book gives you ideas on how to make other pastries.

Pros

• Premium quality pizza stone
• Superior heat conductivity
• Approved by Europe Union and FDA
• Wick moisture
• Durable

Cons

• Quite pricey

#3- Rocksheat Pizza Stone Perfect for Oven, BBQ and Grill

Next in line is a uniquely designed pizza stone from Rocksheat. This rectangular 14 by 16-inch stone features four built-in handles for easy lifting and transporting of pizzas from the oven to the counter. It is well suited for grilling and baking in the grill or an oven.

The stone surface spreads the heat evenly and retains the heat, which gives you a brown crispy crust. It comes with less weight and a perfect thickness that reduces the duration of preheating. 

This pizza stone is thermally stable and does not break when it gets too hot or immersed in water. Burnt in 2200 degrees Fahrenheit, it is free of harmful chemicals and is certified by recognized organizations such as FDA. This product was built to handle extreme heat more than 1000 degrees Fahrenheit. It is perfect for baking bread, cookies, biscuits.

Pros

• Built-in handles
• Food grade quality material
• Perfect gift item
• Retains heat well
• Versatile use for oven and grill

Cons

• Get stain easily

#4- Outset Pizza Grill Stone for charcoal grill

Features four 7.5-inch square-shaped stones that have an excellent thermal shock resistance, which allows you to change the temperature settings of your grill from the lowest heat to extremely high heat without cracking. It is apt to handle temperature up to 787 degrees Celsius, providing you with an evenly brown crust. The stones are safe to use in both a grill and an oven.

This product is built with durable cordierite stones that last longer than regular ceramic. It is fired to about 2000 degrees. Outset pizza grill stone offers adjustable arrangement options that allow you to arrange the stones to suit the size and shape you want. It can be arranged to accommodate the bigger size of pizza for a large group and can also be used individually to grill personal pizzas.

Pros

• Four-piece set
• Evenly brown crust
• Ideal for all kinds of grills and ovens
• Resistant to thermal shock

Cons

• No pizza peel

#5- ROCKSHEAT 14.2″x 0.6″ Round Cordierite Pizza Stone

This round shaped pizza stone by Rocksheat bakes your homemade pizza faster than others. It is built with cordierite which is more durable than ordinary ceramic and will last for years.

The food-grade pizza stone is fired to 2200 degrees Fahrenheit which is resistant to thermal shock and does not contain toxic chemicals or release a foul odour when in use. You don’t have to pre-season the stone before using it. It is ideal for a gas oven, gas grill, electric oven, electric grill, and pellet grill.

This product is constructed to withstand high heat, offering you a crispy crust. You can set the temperature as high as you want without perceiving any foul smell or fear of the stone breaking. It is thicker and heavier, which makes it ideal for baking other foods such as bagel, biscuits, sourdough bread, and cookies.

Pros

• Durable
• Ideal for well-shaped pizzas
• Can withstand up to 1400 degrees
• Does not release any horrible smell

Cons

• Heavy stone
• No handle

#6- Honey-Can-Do Old Stone Oven Rectangular Pizza Stone

Fabricated from natural clay free from lead and other toxic chemicals. This product is solid and does not crack easily. It is an ideal stoneware for baking fresh pizza and also for warming leftovers.

This rectangular-shaped pizza stone helps you bake multiple layers of crunchy crust from your home kitchen. It features raised edges at the base, which makes it easy to carry. Cordierite stone offers even and rapid heating.

This product is durable and sturdy. It is perfect for baking homemade bread and veggies. Discolouration occurs after prolonged use, and this stone pizza is not well suited for cookies and fatty foods. This causes the stone to smoke and spread horrible odour. This 16 by 14-inch Honey can do pizza stone has the ideal thickness of 0.75 that absorbs soggy core and distributes high temperature as it provides you with an evenly baked pizza.

Pros

• Longer shelf life
• Can endure ultra-high heat
• Fits into most oven sizes.
• Superior heat retention

Cons

• Emit smell when in use

#7- Pizzacraft 16.5″ Round ThermaBond Baking/Pizza Stone – for Oven or Grill

A perfect choice for baking in an enclosed oven indoor or an outdoor grill. It bakes crisper and crunchy crust pizzas and home bread just the best way you love to eat them. This 16.5 ring-shaped pizza stone is big enough to serve 4 to 5 persons in one baking. It comes 100% user satisfaction and is replaceable when found with manufacturing defects.

Pizzacraft Stone is constructed from a natural thermabond material that resists thermal shock. It evenly spreads and heats the stone surface to provide you with a golden-brown crust. Providing you with uniformly baked food and removes all hot or cold spots. The surface gets darker with prolonged use. This product does not need to be seasoned before or after use. It is easy to maintain with warm water and soft abrasives. Suitable for baking other pastries and warming frozen pizzas.

Pros

• Refund and replacement guarantee against manufacturing defects
• Approved by FDA
• 100% natural thermabond material
• Ideal for both grill and ovens
• Requires no seasoning before use

Cons

• Smokes a lot

#8- Honey-Can-Do Pizza Stone

The last pizza stone on this list helps you to bake quality pizza that tastes exactly like the one gotten from an eatery. It is versatile and can be used for making other pastries such as biscuits, cookies, bread, vegetables. With its 16-inch size and round shape, you get to bake enough pizza to enjoy with your loved ones.

This product features elevated edges at the bottom that makes it easy to grab when on the grill. It is easy to clean up, maintain, and store. You just have to rinse with warm water and dry. Constructed from a mix of nontoxic clays that do not break or crack. It had a longer life span and suited for high heat up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit. The round shape symmetry restrains your pizza garnishing from falling off.

Pros

• Elevated edges
• Easy maintenance
• Suited for standard ovens
• Even heat circulation

Cons

• Releases awful smell when in use

Types Of Pizza Stones

There are different types of pizza stones and can be categorized under the shape and material. We will be considering the different types of pizza stones based on the material.

A pizza stone is fabricated from different materials that are less likely to get burnt, such as clay, steel, ceramic, cast iron, or cordierite. We will be looking at the most common types.

Ceramic Pizza Stone

Ceramic Pizza Stone is made from 100% natural clay and burnt in a kiln to enhance its heat conduction. It is easy to maintain and can last for a long time if handled properly and with care. This type of stone is lightweight and easy to transport. It is not as expensive as cordierite. Ceramic Pizza Stone retains and evenly circulates heat across all the surfaces.

Clay Pizza Stone

This is one of the best types of pizza stones for baking golden brown pizza. The clay soaks up moisture from the pizza as it bakes. This type of stone comes in different forms and can be moulded at home with hands.

When using clay stones, you will have to preheat for half an hour before you start baking, and they are prone to cracking if not handled with care. It is not easy to maintain.

Cordierite Pizza Stone

Most of this type of pizza stone is constructed in a rectangular form and is a great option for ovens since it is easy to store in an oven as well. It is more pricey and durable.

Cordierite Pizza Stone is built in a way that it adjusts to all kinds of temp settings quickly without cracking or breaking the stone. This option is well suited if you bake more than just pizzas frequently.

Things To Consider Before Buying Pizza Stone For Grill

When it comes to choosing the best pizza stone for your kitchen, your personal needs, preference, and family size must be considered alongside other factors. Here are a few of the things to consider before buying.

Size and Shape

The size of your pizza stone should be able to fit into your grill or oven perfectly without force. It should not be bigger than your grill. So, ensure to get the right size for your oven. The most common size of pizza stone is 14-inch, and it comes with several thickness and diameters.

The shape of a pizza varies. It can be squared, rectangular, or round. The round-shaped pizza stone is perfect for making pizzas; it gives it the round design. However, if you intend to bake other pastries with your pizza stone, you could get other shapes. 

Extra Accessories

Suppose you want a pizza stone with extra accessories such as a recipe book, a cutter, a flipper, or a peel. You could choose our top option from Cuisinart. It comes with a pizza peel and a cutter. The extra accessories make it easy to remove the pizza from the stone and also help you save some extra cash. The cutter is used in cutting the baked pizza. 

Handles

A pizza stone with side handles makes it easy for you to transport the stove into and out of the oven, even when it is still hot. There are several options without handles, and there are few options with handles.

Ways To Use New Pizza Stone

Here is one of the surest ways to use a new pizza stone to its maximum capacity. Firstly you will have to wash the pizza stone before you start to use it. However, some stones do not require to be cleaned. Then you place the pizza stone in a cold oven to start the preheating process.

Without preheating, the stone is liable to cracking or breaking. Turn on your heat source, set to your preferred temp, and heat for 30 minutes before placing your pizza on the stone to bake. Use the lowest shelf in your oven to preheat the stone and avoid placing frozen foods on it because this causes the stone to break.

The pizza dough must have been shaped and kept under room temperature before you set it on the pizza stone. Then you allow baking till you get your desired brown texture. 

When you get your desired crispy texture, use a pizza peel to remove the pizza from the stone before cutting. Then clean with water and allow it to dry before storing.

Conclusion

A pizza stone makes it easy to prepare your pizza from the comfort of your home whenever you like. Maintaining your pizza stone properly will increase the shelf life.

After baking, ensure your pizza stone cools off before you clean to protect it against thermal shock. It is advisable to never clean the pizza stone surface with detergent as there are microscopic pores that absorb them, which will leak into your food when heated.