Best Muffin Pan Reviews America’s Test Kitchen of 2021 & Top Rated

For those that like being busy in the kitchen, using a high-quality baking pan can be a handy and a necessary piece of kitchen equipment for almost every cook. However, to achieve reliable and excellent results each time you bake, it’s important that you use the right muffin pan.

Nevertheless, these products are available in a spectrum of different shapes and sizes and even materials. With such extensive options, choosing the right pan or set of pans can be very tricky.

Fortunately, you don’t have to worry anymore. We’ve reviewed the top 8 best baking pans on the market. So, let’s take you behind the scenes and help you figure out which set or pan works best for you.

Reviews of Best Muffin Pan – Top 7 Pick of the Year

#1. Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Mega Mini Fluted Tube Pan

If you need to bake and cook most of the time, then one pan you can always rely on is Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Mega Mini Fluted Tube Pan. This model comes with heavy-duty steel construction to ensure it serves you well day after day.

Further, this pan comes with a large size to ensure it feeds a lot of hungry stomachs at once. More so, you get oversized handles that offer an excellent grip. Besides, it makes placing it and taking it out of the oven a lot easier.

Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Mega Mini Fluted Tube Pan comes with an ultra-durable non-stick coating to make cleaning up and releasing foods a breeze. This muffin pan will handle all baking jobs from pizza to loaf, cookie sheets, and cake.

Pros:

• Dishwasher safe
• Large baking area
• Oversized handles
• Heavy-duty construction

Cons:

• Filling these cup without creating a mess is nearly impossible

#2. Best Silicone Muffin Set & Cupcake Baking Pan Set (12 & 24 Mini Cup Sizes)

Next on our list is KPKitchen’s Silicone Muffin Pans Set (12 & 24 Mini Cup Sizes) consisting of a 12 cups standard and a 24 cups mini silicone muffin pan. With them you have two pans to make muffin, cupcakes, egg muffins and even keto fat bombs.

KPKitchen also only uses European LFGB-Grade 100% silicone which means no plastic fillers are included and they are completely BPA-free. If you pinch the silicone pans, they don’t turn white which means – no fillers and no additives.

The best thing about the silicone muffin pans is that they are absolutely non-stick which means your muffins just pop out with no effort. They are also heat resistant up to 450°F and oven, freezer and microwave safe.

Also a good point to mention is how easy they are to clean up. The silicone makes cleaning up so quickly with just a little soap but you can also just put them in the  dishwasher. 

For anybody that hasn’t used silicone before, let me tell you that the silicone muffin pans are super easy to use and use can use them for so many different things like Muffin Cakes, Mini Cheesecakes, Tart, Bread, Mousse, Jelly, Keto Fat Bombs, Brownies, Chocolate, Custard & even Soaps.

Pros:

• Set of standard and mini pan
• Easy to clean
• Absolutely non-stick
• 100% Silicone – Pinch-Test approved
• Offers a variety of baking options

Cons:

• Can be a little bit flimsy – best to place them on a baking sheet

#3. Keliwa’s 12 – Cup Silicone Muffin – Cupcake Baking Pan

Next on our list is keliwa’s 12 – Cup Silicone Muffin Cupcake Baking Pan made from high-quality FDA approved materials. Also, its sturdy construction allows this unit to resist high heat and last a lifetime.

Also, you should not expect this pan to rust since it’s constructed from 100% food-grade silicone. In addition, this pan is designed to fit your oven perfectly, which allows you to make the cookie sheet easily.

With keliwa’s 12 – Cup Silicone Muffin – Cupcake Baking Pan, you don’t have to use those messy wrappers or sticky cooking spray. The silicone construction offers non-stick baking and effective heat regulation.

Not just that: its stain-resistant silicone design makes it totally dishwasher safe, which makes cleaning this model simple, quick, and worry-free. This unique construction allows you to fold the pan without causing damage, which means you can easily fold this pan back to its initial shape.

For more value for money, this pan works well not just for muffins alone, but also for mini lasagna cups, chocolate coffee, smoothies, cupcakes, chicken pot pie cups, baked oatmeal cups and a lot more.

Pros:

• Easy to clean
• Heat resistant
• Offers versatile cooking options
• Non-stick baking

Cons:

• Muffins don’t rise compared to metal pans

#4. Premium Non-Stick Best Mini Muffin and Cupcake Pan

For people who love to bake to perfection, then this pan is a must-have for you. This Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Mini Muffin and Cupcake Pan come with premium-grade steel construction to ensure exceptional uniform heat distribution.

This muffin pan features an extremely ample cooking surface to allow you to make large batches quickly and easily. Also, the surface is stain and scratch resistant. This feature helps ensure that this pan remains in good condition for an extended period.

More importantly, this pan comes with a durable non-stick coating, which ensures that cleaning this product is less challenging. This feature means you can easily remove any food residue with ease. On top of this, this model is entirely dishwasher safe.

Pros:

• Easy cleanup process
• Durable non-stick coat
• Oversized handles for an ergonomic grip
• Versatile cooking options

Cons:

• Poor quality control

#5. Wilton Brownie Bar Pan

Whether you are looking to bake once a month or week, Wilton Brownie Bar Pan is an ideal choice for making all your favorite foods. From durable non-stick cooking price to heavy-duty aluminum pans, this model is a top pick.

This silicone pan is the right bakeware to replace your old ones. This unit is available in a plethora of different sizes and shapes, including oblong, square, and round pans, mini, and standard muffin tines. Also, there is 6 to 48 cups and all sort of shapes such as animals, hearts, and common characters loved by kids.

This silicone muffin pan and mold features a spectrum of intriguing shapes that would make your meals a treat to your hungry visitors. Even better, it comes with a unique coating making it scratch resistant and durable non-stick for easy cleanup.

Furthermore, it comes with an ergonomic handle to allow place the pan in and out of the oven with ease. Also, to ensure almost effortless cleanup, the non-stick and scratch-resistant coating makes it all possible.

Pros:

• Non-stick bakeware
• Heavy-duty aluminum pan
• Easy to clean
• Available in a lot of sizes and shapes

Cons:

• Likely to stuck even after seasoning

#6. To encounter Non-Stick BPA Free 41pcs Silicone Round Cake

Another high-quality pan made from 100% food-grade silicone, BPA free, and FDA approved materials. With super non-stick and flexible materials, this pan is completely dishwasher safe. Also, you get a high heat resistant pan, capable of withstanding heat up to 450 degrees F.

Also, it’s silicone molds are ideal for baking bread, muffins, cupcakes, and baking doughnuts. Besides, they are ideal for preparing baking cheesecakes, layer cakes, birthday cake, cornbread, coffee cake, and more.

Talking about versatility, silicone molds are perfect for baking bread, muffins, cupcakes, and baking doughnuts. Also, you can use it for baking layer cakes, coffee cake, birthday cake, cornbread, and a lot more. Even better, it includes a heat-resistant glove to ensure you can safely cook and bake with this pan.

Pros:

• 100% food-grade silicone, BPA free
• Non-stick – easy food release
• Safe to use
• Reusable baking mold

Cons:

• Can’t handle high temperature

#7. Tosnail Non-stick Giant Cupcake Pan

This is a top choice for a giant cupcake pan. This model is constructed with super quality carbon steel to ensure impressive, even heating. Coming with incredible mold design, Tosnail Non-stick Giant Cupcake Pan will help you create astonishing, huge 3D cupcakes always.

That’s not all: there’s a non-stick coating to ensure the quick release and almost effortless clean up. Although this pan is dishwasher safe, it’s recommended that you hand wash for effectiveness.

Also, it comes with sculptural design features to allow fun and charming decoration, which helps make any occasion, including birthday special.

Pros:

• Constructed of premium quality carbon steel
• Beautiful, huge 3D cupcake
• Sculptural details design
• Nonstick coating

Cons:

• Instructions are not included

#8. Norpro Giant Muffin Cups

Coming with a huge muffin cups, this unit is a top choice for anyone looking to create giant muffins. This product includes 100 muffin cups, each made from food-safe white paper to ensure healthy meals.

This unique construction ensures your muffin sides are soft and nice, which also prevents any possible burning. Even better, these muffin pans are sturdy and very easy to pop out. Norpro Giant Muffin Cups are way easy to cleanup.

Pros:

• 100 muffin cups
• Extra-large size
• Sturdy and easy to pop out
• Easy pan cleanup

Cons:

• May not be an ideal choice for large parties

Things to Consider Before Choosing the Best Muffin Pan on the Market

The ideal baking pan should be able to help you create perfectly baked food without lots of hassle. However, it’s evident that not all models on the market are capable of achieving this with impressive results.

In lieu of this, we’ve compiled a few factors that you keep in mind when choosing the right muffin pan to offer incredible results.

Durable Construction

When splurging on a muffin pan, it’s important that you ensure it’s a one-time investment. Therefore, you must ensure the unit can offer long-lasting performance.

Most muffin pan sets are made of carbon steel, glass heavy-gauge steel, aluminum, and tempered steel. Although these material options share a couple of similarities, including durability, they differ in several ways, which makes them unique.

Further, you should make sure the materials are lab-test or FDA-approved. This ensures that chemicals or toxins are not getting into your food.

Oven Size

For beginners, the size of your oven is important in ensuring a pleasant experience. Purchasing a pan that doesn’t fit into your oven can be a totally wrong choice.

Therefore, ensure that you determine the length, depth, and width of your oven before making a choice. For example, if you have a small oven, then you should consider purchasing a smaller muffin pan or set of pans.

Non-stick Coating

Another thing worth considering is the sort of non-stick coating. You want to make sure that the pan requires minimal effort to separate your muffin pan from your food. This is where non-stick coating comes handy.

Further, this feature makes it cleaning this pan a breeze. On top of that, it helps ensure maximum durability. The best muffin pan should feature BPA-free non-stick coating to make sure your food is safe.

Ease of Maintenance

Most muffin pans are dish-washable. This is one of the features to look out for when it comes to choosing the right set of the pan if you don’t want to spend a lot of time hand washing every piece.

In addition, you should consider purchasing a pan that’s easy to replace or even repair. Also, you should consider how easy maintaining the muffin pan would be in the long run.

Heating Quality

When it comes to this factor, the two most important things to consider its heat retention and heating speed. Since you’ll have to preheat the oven before baking first, it’s essential that your muffin pan immediately heat up fast.

In general, materials such as aluminum and copper tend to heat up as quick as possible. However, silicone and glass materials heat up slowly.

Conclusion

We’ve done our part and reviewed the best muffin pan on the market. However, it’s up to you to choose the right unit that works best for you.