The Best Ice Cream Scoop America’s Test Kitchen, Consumer Reports of 2021

Having a nice bowl of ice cream is just the thing to consume after a busy day under hot weather. For ice cream lovers, finding the best ice cream scoop America’s Test Kitchen whose use they can enjoy, without exerting a great deal of effort, is quite important.

Scoops are designed to streamline this simple enough task that could get messy when mishandled.

However, there are many unique designs featured on different products in the market. There are scoops shaped like a spade while some others come with pointy ends; some are big and quite heavy while some are lightweight and compact.

Reviews of Best Ice Cream Scoop American’s Test Kitchen

Here are top rated Ice Cream Scoop by consumer reports

#1 – Spring Chef Ice Cream Scoop With Comfortable Handle

This model is constructed using zinc alloy, which prevents rusting or corroding of the product. The handle is very comfortable and comes with a non-slip rubber coating on the surface that acts as an insulator against cold transfer. This model features a spade-like shape at the front of the scoop with a deep pocket to enable easy scooping of your ice cream.

There are no extra components on the scoop that are liable to break off; you can wash the product in the dishwasher without damaging its appearance. The model comes in six colors you can choose from to complement your kitchen design. A lifetime warranty comes with every purchase of this product.

You can easily make beautiful scoops with this high-end piece of kitchen equipment; the design and other complementing features are sure to give you the best performance money can get.

Pros:

• The construction is durable and sturdy
• Dishwasher safe
• Rubber insulator on the handle
• High-quality performance
• Lifetime warranty

Cons:

• Can’t be used with hard ice cream

#2 – Stainless Steel Ice Cream Scoop by Midnight Scoop

This model features an elegant yet precise design, which is sure to catch your attention; you can use this product to conveniently scoop and slide your ice cream into your bowl without overexerting yourself. The featured handle makes that possible with a design that eliminates the prying motion, which causes strain on your wrist joints.

This model is perfect for individuals who have weak wrists and stress when scooping up their ice cream. Stainless steel was used to construct the product, which is very durable and strong enough to cut into your hard ice cream. The product can be washed using a dishwasher without accumulating damage on the surface.

A lifetime warranty comes with every unit of this model; the product can be easily replaced by simply reaching out to the company. The scoop is lightweight and compact for easy movement and storage. This model was designed by an Aerospace Engineer to guarantee lifetime performance.

Pros:

• Lifetime warranty
• Excellent user experience
• Dishwasher safe
• Can cut through hard ice cream

Cons

• Can be small for some users

#3 – Solula Stainless Steel Large Ice Cream Scoop Disher Melon Baller 4 Tablespoon

The size of this model is perfect for any individual to work without any inconvenience. A squeeze and release handle is featured on this product, which creates an easy and effective way of scooping up your neat balls of ice cream as well as other food applications.

The scoop is lightweight and made using 18/8 stainless steel, which makes it very resistant to damage, chipping, corrosion, or bending. This product is an excellent option sure to provide reliable performance for years to come. There is a 2-year warranty on this model from the manufacturer.

The versatile design, combined with high-quality materials and construction, gives way into a first-rate product that you need to have around in your kitchen. The Solula scoop was also designed to accommodate individuals who have weak wrists and can’t exert too much force; you can easily push into your ice cream through this use of this premium scoop.

Pros:

• Strong and durable construction
• Dishwasher safe
• Available in different sizes
• Lightweight and easy to store

Cons:

• Relatively expensive
• It takes some time to learn its use

#4 – SUMO Ice Cream Scoop: Solid Stainless Steel. Dishwasher Safe

The Sumo scoop is made using heavy-duty stainless steel, which can never bend, snap, or damage in reaction to an applied force. The tool is BPA free making it an excellent option to procure; this model features a chiseled tip, which is hard enough to pick up solid molds of ice cream. 

This product comes in four color variants for you to pick from; with a backing of a lifetime warranty and the functional design, you are sure to enjoy the use of this product without stressing yourself.

The handle is rubber-coated, which insulates the cold from the ice cream for you; the non-slip nature of the handle makes it convenient to use. You can make use of a dishwasher to maintain this quality equipment from Sumo; the size of the material is compact and small for easy use and storage. 

Pros:

• Nearly indestructible build
• Dishwasher safe
• Lifetime warranty
• Small and compact design

Cons:

• Comes in a single size option

#5 – OXO 1191000 Good Grips Solid Stainless Steel Ice Cream Scoop

This is a beautiful and simple model designed by OXO Good Grips known for their quality products. The product features a stainless steel build with a rubber handle for a good grip and control. The handle is also non-slip and helps insulate against cold transfer onto your hand; there is also a loop on the handle, which allows the product to be easily stored for later use.

A pointy tip is on the other end of the handle, which has a capacity of 3 tablespoons; you can easily dig into the hard ice cream you are trying to get a piece of. When you are done eating your ice cream, you can simply put the tool in the dishwasher for cleaning.

There are flat edges on the sides to arm you in reaching every corner of your ice cream container. The product is BPA-free, which is featured for the safety of the users. The OXO Good Grips scoop comes with a lifetime warranty in case you need to replace your unit later.

Pros:

• Durable construction and built for comfort
• Dishwasher safe
• Lifetime warranty
• Versatile option

Cons:

• A bit heavy

#6 – BALCI Professional Stainless Ice Cream Scoop

The Balci Ice Cream is an ergonomic model constructed using stainless steel with a rubber handle for a better grip. The stainless steel ensures the product is resistant to damage, cracking, or bending; this is a heavy-duty model built for professional use. The rubber handle is BPA-free as well as non-slip and insulated to provide convenient user experience to any individual employing its use.

You can make use of a dishwasher to handle the maintenance of the product without incurring any damage on the surface. The scoop also comes with a lifetime warranty to cover any returns the owners might be interested in.

This product by Balci has been tested and proven to cut through hard ice cream without exerting much force. There are six different colors to choose from to match your kitchen decor. The compact design grants the users of this model easy storage and handling.

Pros:

• Features a smart pointed tip for easy scooping
• Built using stainless steel which makes the product robust and durable
• Comes in different color variants
• Safe for cleaning with a dishwasher

 Cons

• May be smaller than expected

#7 – Wilton 417-1112 Stainless Steel Cookie Scoop

Designed with a spring lever mechanism that enables easy scooping of hard ice cream out of the container, this product is certain to give you a return value and performance for your money. The product is built using stainless steel, which makes it sturdy and durable enough to withstand the test of time.

You can scoop up uniform balls of ice cream effortlessly with the 4-teaspoon capacity of the product. However, this model can accommodate only handwashing for maintenance; they are not compatible for use with dishwashers. The product comes in a single color, silver, and features squeeze-handles, which makes the entire task easier.

Pros:

• Strong build
• Convenient spring mechanism
• Easy to clean
• Efficient design

Cons:

• Handwashing only

How to Pick the Best Ice Cream Scoop

To be able to scoop up perfect mold balls of ice cream effortlessly, we’ve gathered a few things to assist you in making the best product that suits your needs. Here are the factors you need to put into consideration when buying an ice cream scoop.

Material

You need to opt for scoops constructed using durable and sturdy materials; such materials are certain to serve you for a long period with efficiency. High-quality materials like stainless steel or aluminum are suitable for use. Stainless steel models are the most durable with the ability to resist any bending force. However, they tend to be resistant to rust, which is why you should consider going for an aluminum model. Aluminum models are also durable and designed to withstand the test of time.

Construction Style

The design of a scoop can affect its efficiency and performance; there are several sizes and shapes of scoops, so you need to pick the right size and shape you know you can work with. You need to choose a model that has a comfortable handle to be able to grip your scoop properly.

Some models feature the use of a spring-loaded lever, which scoops and slides the ice cream out. Another kind of scoop is the push-out models whose functionality is similar to the spring-loaded design; this is the most common kind.

Warranty

This is one other thing to consider before buying; different warranty conditions are provided by the brands in the market. It’s recommended that you go for a model that has a longer warranty, such models are often high-quality whose manufacturers are certain about the value of their products. Some of the popular models in the market offer a refund policy as well as a free replacement warranty to cover their use.

Maintenance

These simple tools don’t require a great deal of care when it comes to maintaining the look and functionality. Some models can be cleaned through the use of a dishwasher, while some are incompatible with its use for maintenance. Unless explicitly stated, it’s best to wash the scoop through hand cleaning.

Conclusion

You can select from the options provided above, compare the features and price of each model to determine the perfect ice cream scoop that suits your needs or requirements. A fairly-priced model with a durable build and good grip should serve you long enough to enjoy its use.