The Best Cookie Scoop America’s Test Kitchen, Consumer Reports of 2021

Cookie scoops are hemispherical spoon-like utensils for special purposes, usually for baking. They are sometimes referred to as dishers. A cookie scoop is a must-have if you enjoy baking and making home-made treats such as cookies and muffins.

Their use also extended to serve other cooking purposes such as shaping and delivering meatballs, melons, etc. Their versatility makes them invaluable in any kitchen, helping you to deliver precise measurements of dough and other food materials uniform and consistent sizes and shapes.

Cookie scoops feature a characteristic wiper of a loaded spring that ensures that its contents are delivered totally without sticking to the scoop.

We have selected five unique cookie scoops that we are confident will satisfy your needs, and below is a review of our top 5 picks best cookie scoop America’s Test Kitchen.

WHY DO I NEED A COOKIE SCOOP?

The most obvious advantage of using a cookie scoop instead of a spoon (or your hands) to transfer cookie dough from the mixing bowl to the cookie sheet is that it creates consistency—each cookie is the exact same size, shape, and diameter.

While uniform cookies make for an appealing, professional-looking final presentation, Garten believes that they also ensure that the cookies bake evenly and, as a result, taste great.

In addition, using a scoop keeps your hands clean and speeds up the shaping process. I’m not sure how many times I can say it, but if you’re wondering if this kitchen tool is worth it, it is.

WHAT SIZE COOKIE SCOOPS SHOULD I GET?

The size of the cookie scoop you should use is determined by several factors, including how much the cookie dough you’re working with will spread and the size of the cookies you’d like to eat. Cookie scoops in sizes ranging from #70 (which dispenses about 2 tsp. of dough) to #30 are common (2 Tbsp.).

Because a cookie dough scoop is essentially an ice cream scoop, the numbers correspond to the number of scoops that can be obtained from a quart of ice cream—the higher the number, the smaller the scoop.

We recommend using a #30 or #40 scoop, which holds about 112 Tbsp, for most cookie recipes. made of dough To make a slightly larger cookie, such as our favorite chocolate chip cookies ever, use a #20 cookie scoop, which holds about 3 Tbsp. made of dough

REVIEWS OF BEST COOKIE SCOOP AMERICA’S KITCHEN TEST

Here are top rated 5 Cookie Scoop on the market today

#1 – OXO Good Grips Medium Cookie Scoop

The Oxo Good grips medium cookie scoop like its name says. This unit offers tremendous grip support that allows you to pick up the dough easily while retaining a solid grasp on its handle.

It is a medium-sized cookie scoop of #40 size (about 1.5 tablespoons); hence it is only capable of making small scoops of cookie dough. It will yield a cookie of about 3/4 of an inch in diameter, which is a great size for a cookie, and you can count on a consistent and uniform delivery.

If you have an intent to use your cookie scoop for ice-creams, you will only be able to deliver small scoops with this product. The Oxo medium cookie scoop features a spring-loaded wiper that helps you deliver scoops cleanly and with precision.

Other than the non-slip plastic grip, the scoop is made entirely of stainless steel, which is easy to clean on its own but is also dishwasher friendly.

Pros:

• Clean ejection and precise delivery of dough
• Consistent and uniform sized dough
• Soft, comfortable Non-slip grip
• Dishwasher safe

Cons:

• Falls apart easily when not properly handled
• No warranty

#2 – Jenaluca Cookie Scoop – Mini Cupcake Scoop

This is another medium-sized cookie scoop with an all-stainless steel sleek and ergonomic design. It is optimized to conform to your hands, letting you scoop in comfort.

It has a highly durable build that can handle heavy-duty work without breaking down. The Jenaluca cookie scoop is mirror polished, so it shines after every wash as it does when you first buy it. The stainless steel is easy to clean and is dishwasher friendly.

The total metallic frame design makes it slippery to grip sometimes and would require more focus to keep the scoop firmly on the hand. The wiper works perfectly, though, providing a clean and total ejection of dough. The scoop is ideal for a different number of purposes, from cookies to making cupcakes, delivery ice-cream and making Swedish meatballs, the Jenacula Cookie scoop is as versatile as they come.

Pros:

• Impressive versatility
• Highly durable frame
• Clean ejection and delivery of dough
• Ergonomic design
• Easy to clean
• Incredible versatility

Cons:

• Slippery grip

#3 – KitchenAid (KN148OHSBA) Gourmet Best Cookie Dough Scoop

KitchenAid is a well-known name in the kitchen appliance industry, noted for making high-quality and affordable kitchen utensils and appliances.

The Gourmet Cookie Dough Scoop is made of durable and well crafted stainless steel with a touch of rubber on the handle to ensure a non-slip grip. It is medium-sized and capable of scooping 1.5 tablespoons of dough at one scoop. The utensil is easy to handle and highly convenient to use.

The spring-loaded mechanism doesn’t require guesswork and helps with a clean and total delivery of the scoop’s content. The scoop can also be employed in a number of different fashions other than cookie dough. It is capable of scooping ground beef for meatballs, and melon for fruit salad.

The product is easy to clean. It is also dishwasher friendly. The manufacturers have guaranteed a one-year replacement and lifetime limited warranty as a show of their confidence in the scoop’s durability.

Pros:

• Sturdy, well-crafted design
• Incredible versatility
• Efficient and clean delivery of scoops
• Replacement and lifetime warranty
• Non-slip, ergonomic grip

Cons:

• Falls apart easily

#4 – Nepro Stainless Steel Cookie Scoops

These come as a set with the three important sizes you will need for all your baking and serving purposes. The sizes are 1 tablespoon, 1.5 tablespoons, and 2 tablespoons.

The Nepro stainless steel cookie scoop set features a heavy-duty spring action that releases food easily with precision. The stainless steel has a high polished finish that keeps it shiny and bright after every cleanup. It prevents it from rusting or corroding.

Without a plastic, wooden, or rubber handle, the scoops can be challenging to handle. It can slip off easily and can also stress and bite into the hand.

The set is highly versatile, enabling you to move different quantities of food items with high precision. The sets are capable of scooping ice-cream, cookie, and dough. Also, it can make meatballs as well as fruit and melon balls.

The stainless steel scoops from Nepro are also very easy to clean and can be washed with a dishwasher. They are quite durable despite their incredible performance.

Pros:

• Highly durable metallic frame
• Easy to clean and dishwasher friendly
• Impressive versatility
• Effective delivery system

Cons:

• The metallic handle is not comfortable to use
• Buying a set at once is costly

#5 – Jenaluca Cookie Scoop Set – Stainless Steel Cookie Scoop, lce Cream Scooper, Melon Baller

This one a three-piece set of the same incredible quality. Jenacula employed a high-end, premium grade 18/8 stainless steel to ensure the sturdiness and performance of their scoop set.

This stainless steel is carefully modeled into an easy to use scoop set that stands apart in a league of its own. The set includes a 1.5 tablespoon scoop, a 2 tablespoon scoop, and a 3 tablespoon scoop, designated as small, medium, and large. They are quite easy to use. The spring is highly responsive and releases its content without requiring excess pressure.

They are also very versatile and will do a great job not just at scooping cookie and dough, but also with ice-cream cones, handling truffles and other small vegetables. More so, it helps in making meatballs, mini-cupcakes, muffins, collecting, and distributing candy and melon balls.

They are made entirely of stainless steel and are just as easy to clean. They wash thoroughly under the dishwasher and retain their color.

Pros:

• Easy to use
• Delivers food effectively
• Easy to clean and dishwasher friendly
• Highly versatile
• Impressive durability

Cons:

• The set is costly
• Slippery grip

Cookie Scoop Sizes

Most manufacturers usually offer cookie scoop in three basic sizes: Large, medium, and small. However, cookie Scoop sizes have a weird measurement that can be confusing for buyers, that is why we have taken the initiative to bring you the most popular sizes and give you the approximate equivalent in more familiar measurements.

Of course, the size of your cookie scoop is a major factor in how large your cookies will come out, many other factors, especially with your ingredients and the dough making process determine the size of the cookie once you are done baking.

So, with the clarified measurement above, you should be able to choose the ideal cookie scoop for you. Better still, if you can spare the money, you can buy a set.

Things to Consider When Shopping for a Cookie Scoop

In order to help you make an informed decision, we will be discussing the most vital features to consider in a cookie scoop. They include:

1. Size

Every baker has a rough idea of what he/she wants to make, and this usually directs how the prep session goes. If you are thinking of getting a cookie scoop, you most likely know what size and output you require. The problem comes when you purchase the wrong size and run into trouble getting the desired result.

Hence, the size of your scoop has to be one of the foremost things to pay attention to when buying a cookie scoop. The scoop size table above helps to relate scoop sizes with common measuring terms to give you a clear understanding of the scoop size you see.

2. Ergonomics and Design

The design of your cookie scoop goes beyond its aesthetic value; it decides how convenient and comfortable the scoop will be to use. Ideally, you want something with padded handles. Cookie scoops with a full metallic frame are difficult to handle for extended periods; they may bite into the palms and give you sores.

There is also the issue of grip, a rubber or plastic handle offers a better grip that will let you take a full scoop in one move compared to an edgy, and slippery metallic frame. Some manufacturers design their scoop in strange manners, to say the least, they are not comfortable to hold. A scoop that conforms to a person’s natural hand form makes scooping work easy and smooth.

3. Ease of cleaning

Cookie scoops do some heavy-duty work, transferring sticky and viscous dough. To save yourself the hassle of that comes with the cleanup portion that follows every baking, you should ensure that your scoop is made out of easy to clean material. Stainless steel is best in this regard; it is sturdy and easy to clean. And usually dishwasher friendly.

4. Durability

Low-grade cookie scoops spoil quickly, especially at the fulcrum. An investment in a high-quality and durable cookie scoop is usually worth its price. Special caution should also be taken in handling these utensils to ensure that they last longer.

Conclusion

Your choice of best cookie scoop is highly dependent on your baking goals and preferences. You have to select one that will work well for you. We have carefully researched the market to bring you these reviews as well as the general buying guide to follow to identify and purchase high-quality cookie scoops that will ease your baking process.

Also, you should be careful in handling them as well as storage, so as to maximize their lifespan as they break down easily without cautious storage.

Frequently Asked Questions