The Best Brownie Pan Reviews America’s Test Kitchen of 2021

Not many things are as delicious as a pack of perfectly baked brownies in the world, especially when it’s hot out of the oven. Either you are a fan of the crispy corners or the gooey middle piece, the market is filled with a wide range of best brownie pans to pick from to suit your needs.

With such a plethora of options, choosing a product becomes tricky and overwhelming. However, we’ve done our homework and carefully handpicked pans with no cold or hot spots, and features excellent nonstick qualities to offer quick release.

Without further ado, let’s consider the best brownie pans on the market. But before that, let’s take a quick look at key factors to put into consideration before making a choice.

Best Brownie Pan Reviews – Top 7 Recommendation of the Year

Here are best selling brownie pan by consumer report

Top 1 – Baker’s Edge Nonstick Edge Brownie Pan

Our top choice for brownies lovers is Baker’s Edge Nonstick Edge Brownie Pan. It is one of the best brownie pans with moist centers and a plethora of chewy edges. This fantastic unit is made with pride in the USA. It’s designed to include two chewy edges to your baked brownie.

Also, the funky interior walls are geared towards subliming your baking performance with even heat circulation to the middle of the pan (since these parts take longer to bake). That’s not all: Baker’s Edge Nonstick Edge Brownie Pan features a super heavy-duty and nonstick construction, which ensures that this model never wraps and doesn’t take a lot of time to clean.

Even better, there is an included recessed handle to ensure users can easily grab this pan and turn upside down. Each unit comes with a flexible nylon spatula, which completes this pan and also a brownie recipes insert, which will come in handy.

Also, Baker’s Edge Nonstick Edge Brownie Pan features a continuous chamber to offer more room for the batter to spread out easily. Further, this brownie pan fits standard box mixes without having to deal with the stress of adjusting to ensure a snug fit.

Pros:

• Single baking chamber
• Nonstick cooking surface
• Uniform heat circulation
• Three interior sidewalls
• Easy to clean

Cons:

• Cutting with the scapula isn’t easy as you would expect

Top 2 – GOTHAM STEEL Brooklyn Brownie Copper Nonstick Baking Pan

Our runner up is GOTHAM STEEL Brooklyn Brownie Copper Nonstick Baking Pan, offering just about everything in a single pan. This model allows you to blend your batter inside the pan with an electric mixer without dealing with peeling or scratches afterward,

Also, with GOTHAM STEEL Brooklyn Brownie Copper Nonstick Baking Pan, you can bake your brownie in your oven up to 500-degree Fahrenheit and slides out of the pan without having to use a lot of oil.

Even better, the pan’s bottom can be used as a serving tray after you take out the divider. Not just for brownies alone, you can make tasty mini cakes with this brownie pan. Further, its cooking versatility extends to making pre sliced pizza squares to make your lunch a lot of fun.

Another incredible thing about GOTHAM STEEL Brooklyn Brownie Copper Nonstick Baking Pan is a nonstick coating, which ensures cleaning after baking a breeze. You can also make rice Krispy treat and be assured of easy cleaning even without using butter or oil.

Pros:

• Super strong nonstick surface
• Easy pop out without oil or butter
• Dishwasher safe
• Can mix in the pan with an electric mixer

Cons:

• For best cleaning results, you have to hand wash, which obviously will be time-consuming

Top 3 – Wilton Brownie Bar Pan

Coming up next on our list of best brownie pan reviews is Wilton Brownie Bar Pan. This pan is a top choice for people looking to make individual bar cookies, brownies square or mini cakes.

This pan is crafted from steel to ensure impressive durability and longevity. Plus, its non stick surface coating makes it easy to clean up without taking all day. Besides, nonstick pans allow users to release the brownies hassle-free quickly.

Further, the surface features a scratch-resistant coating to add another layer of durability. Wilton Brownie Bar Pan is designed to be dishwasher safe. Even better, it comes with heavy-duty aluminum construction, which offers uniform heating throughout the pan.

To sweeten the deal, this model is accompanied by an impressive 10-year warranty, which protects your investment. More so, you’ll be baking with silicone, which means you don’t have to grease the pan before use, and your brownies will come out quickly without overcooking or burning food.

Pros:

• Fast baking
• No need for greasing
• Limited 10-year warranty
• Heavy-duty aluminum construction

Cons:

• Poor quality control

Top 4 – Fat Daddio’s POB-8122 Sheet Cake Pan

This model from Fat Daddio comes with an ideal shape perfect for lasagnas, casseroles, bar-type cookies, pastries, cakes, and brownies. Fat Daddio’s POB-8122 Sheet Cake Pan is the first pan on this list with an anodized aluminum surface, which makes this pan stronger and safer to bake with,

Also, there’s a non-reactive yet durable finish to cook a wide range of recipes includes savory and citrus-based recipes. Since this pan is designed to reflect heat more than absorb heat, this pan can easily get heated up and cools down quickly.

On top of that, you get even heating to ensure you get an optimal rise. Since it cools quicker, your chances of over-baking your brownie get slimmer. Lastly, the coating and finish lack chemical additives, PFOA, PTFE, and dye.

Pros:

• Cools and heats cool quicker
• Anodized aluminum
• No chemical or extra metals coatings
• Built to be tough

Cons:

• Tends to wrap

Top 5 – Bakelicious 73843 Crispy Corner Brownie Pan

Another well-constructed pan with an impressive nonstick coating is Bakelicious 73843 Crispy Corner Brownie Pan. This model is crafted from durable carbon steel to ensure quick and hassle-free release. This bakeware will make 12 brownies with crispy edges at once.

After baking, this pan easily flips, and with gentle taps, your brownies get released and ready to serve. Bakelicious 73843 Crispy Corner Brownie Pan comes with a separate brownie batter to bake your brownie faster compared to the traditional style pan.

Even better, you can easily check for doneness periodically using a toothpick or cake tester during baking. Sadly, this bakeware is not dishwasher safe and requires hand washing for effective cleanliness.

Pros:

• Cooks faster than traditional style pan
• Brownies come with crispy edges
• Durable carbon steel
• Nonstick coating

Cons:

• Not dishwasher safe

Top 6 – CHEFMADE Brownie Cake Pan, 12-Cavity Non-Stick Square Muffin Pan

When it comes to safety and healthy cooking, you can’t really go wrong purchasing CHEFMADE Brownie Cake Pan, 12-Cavity Non-Stick Square Muffin Pan. This model is FDA approved with a food-grade silicone coating without any harmful substances, including PFOA and PTFE.

Further, it comes with carbon steel to offer accelerated uniform heat. Its incredible construction prevents warping and convenient use. Also, it helps ensure an extended service life. Furthermore, its excellent nonstick square pan makes it possible to cook without using a lot of natural cooking oil.

Therefore, you can bake within a short period without consuming a lot of energy. Also, it easier to release the brownies and clean the pan.

Pros:

• Commercial grade construction
• Safe and health to bake with
• Easy to use
• Capable of feeding for a lot of people at once
• Withstand high heat

Cons:

• Brownies may not come out of the pan easily

Top 7 – SUJUDE Non-Stick Brownie Pans with Dividers, Divided Brownie Pan

Last but not least, excellent brownie pan on the market. This model is made of high-carbon steel, which offers terrific heat transfer, excellent even heat distribution, and delivers perfectly baked edge brownies.

Even more, it comes with a 100% nonstick technology featuring a platinum 3X3 layer spraying technology. This makes this unit stain-resistant, nonstick, and non-corrosion. As such, this bakeware is hassle-free to clean and safe to bake your brownies.

Pros:

• Fast and even heating
• Features nonstick technology
• Made of high carbon steel
• Makes 18 perfectly sliced brownies at a time

Cons

• The edges could be better

Things to Consider When Choosing the Best Brownie Pan

Types of Pans

Traditional

This is the most common option, which it comes to the style of brownie bakeware. They are available in rectangular and square shapes. They do not come with any kind of special features or dividers other than handles or lips on specific models.

They are suitable for people who tend to pour batter into the bakeware and place in your oven without a lot of fuss and excess preparation.

Molded

This type of pan comes with individual cavities as opposed to a single ample one. They require a tad of precision and accuracy, especially when you have to prevent spills while adding batter. Nevertheless, since you don’t spend time cutting the brownies into servings, this model is a top choice for people looking to save a lot of time baking their favorite brownie.

Further, these pans are available in multiple cavity options, with the rectangle and square being the common options. The market is also filled with different fun shapes. The most striking thing with these pans is its versatility, which makes it ideal to use a cake mold.

Removal features

Non-stick

These bakeware features a nonstick surface to allow your brownies to slide out of the pan after baking. That’s not only what you get with a nonstick coating. They also make it easy to clean the pan after baking with easy stuck-on food removal.

This feature is excellent for people on a tight budget, but still don’t want to spend all day cleaning the system.

Pop-out

Pop-out bakewares for brownies are crafted using food-grade silicone. Featuring such remarkable flexibility, this pan makes it way easier to pop or push your brownies out without any hassle.

There are also other options on the market made with aluminum but featuring a silicone bottom, which brings the best of both worlds to your table.

Removable grid

This baking pan comes with a grid that fits the pan perfectly. They bear a lot of resemblance to the old-fashioned metal ice-cube trays, but without any struggle pouring the batter into the grid and baking. Immediately, your brownies are done, you get perfectly pre sliced brownies straight out of the grid.

Dividers

Like removable grids, dividers also fit the main pan but available in squares rather than round shapes like the muffin pans. They are built with easy individual brownie dislodgement in mind. Sadly, these pans are not so different from muffin pans in terms of cleaning. You may have to spend a while cleaning the nooks and crannies of these pans.

Conclusion

We’ve come to the end of the best brownie pans available to offer incredible value for your money. However, it’s up to you to make a choice based on your cooking needs. But we are confident that whichever you choose, you can’t really go wrong.